Internet Academy ALP Reading
Assessment Lessons Helpful Tools Rubrics Index Home
Federal Way Public Schools  
Thinking Critically
Lesson 19
Evaluating Reasons and Ideas
 Objectives/Vocab/Tips > Examples: 1 | 2 > Practice: 1 | 2 > Self Check

Example 1:

Instruction:

The American dollar bill looks ordinary to us. We use it everyday. But it holds some interesting secrets. Read, "Mysteries of the American Dollar." If you have a dollar with you, pull it out to examine as you read. The article is linked to the book icon on the right.

The question for this passage asks you to use your thinking skills to form your own opinion from information in the article. Get those thinking skills ready.


Mysteries of the American Dollar

Short Answer Prompt:

Do you agree or disagree with the following information?

The more valuable the money, the more likely people are to hide it.

Use two details from the selection to support your answer.

Remember in an example exercise, you are working with scoring and evaluting answers already written. Included in this example are a two point and a one point written response. See if you can determine which is which. First, let's look at the criteria used to evaluate the two responses.

  • A two point response agrees or disagrees with the statement and provides two text-based details to support the position.
  • A one point response agrees or disagrees with the statement and provides one text-based detail to support the position.
  • A zero point answer might be "I don't know." Or it might not state an agreement or disagreement, or may not provide text-based support of opinion.
  • Now you might want to take just a few minutes and write your own TWO point response so you have something to compare to the two other responses.

Here are the two different responses. Evaluate and score each response.

Student 1 writes:

I agree that the more valuable the money, the more likely people are to hide it. I know this beacuse in the selection it says that 91% of the Americans hide all of their $100 bills. It also says that the Federal Reserve Bank replaces around $100 million every day.

Score this response:

2
1
0

Student 2 writes:

Yes, I agree with the statement. "Did you know, for instance, that Americans hide about 91$ of all their $100 bills? We tuck them away in jars, mattresses, wall safes, hollow trees, or other secret places."

Score this response:

2
1
0

Let's look at one more example.

 

Example 2 >>

 

Assessments Vocabulary

©Internet Academy