You read "From the Land and Back"
while you worked on the Rubrics: Multiple Choice
section of this course. Remember it is about a farmer
and two families who camp on his land with their
wagons and stock. Read it again, but this time:
Read the question first,
Look for clues about the farmer as you read. One
tip that will work for this question is to read
the choice answers, considering each one to see
if there are clues or hints that make the answer
true.
Click on the book icon to the
right.Then
we'll see what inference we can make from the clues
about the farmer in the story. Keep the passage open
as we work through this example.
Which idea does the selection suggest about the farmer?
Remember:The
word "suggest" indicates the answer
is not going to be directly stated. The author is giving
hints or clues in describing the actions of the character
and the reader is to make an inference. This question
could also be stated this way: What inference can
you make about the farmer?
Remember to:
Read the question before reading the
passage.
Look for clues about the farmer as you read. The strategy
we will use for this question is a bit different than
we have used before. We are going to make a question out
of each answer and see if there are clues in the passage
to make an accurate inference.
Think:
What are the key
words in this question? (idea,
suggest about the farmer)
Which choices can you eliminate
right away, and which are possibly correct answers? Remember
the "YES, NO, MAYBE" tool.
Multiple Choice Answers:
Yes
No
Maybe
Answers
A.
He is reluctant to have visitors stay on his land. Turn
this to a question:
Was the farmer reluctant to have visitors stay on
his land?
You
might need to check a dictionary for the word "reluctant."
Webster's
Online and Dictionary.com
are both good sources, or keep a dictionary
close by when you read! Here it means hesitant or
unwilling.
Was
the farmer reluctant (unwilling) to
have visitors stay on his land?
Find
clues in the passage: When the first group
of visitors asks if they can stay on the farmer's
land for the night, the farmer agrees. The passage
says,"The favor readily granted,"
which means the farmer quickly said "Sure
thing," or something like it. He certainly was
not unwilling. "Readily" is the opposite
of reluctant. If we need further proof, we also read,
"Late in the evening, their host strolled
down to see if everything was all right, and to pick
up any news they might have." A farmer who
was unwilling would not do this. This
choice has to be NO. We cannot infer the
farmer was reluctant because the clue in the story
says he readily agreed. Eliminate this answer quickly.
B.
He himself would like to travel. Turn
this to a question:
Are there clues in the story to make me believe the
farmer would like to travel?
The
farmer says nothing about traveling himself.
He
welcomes the travelers, and listens to them, but
does not ask questions about their travels.
He
offers his opinion about the nature of people, but
does not ask to go with his visitors.
After
reading the selection carefully, we might infer
the farmer is content(comfortable,
happy) on his farm, because he does not
express any interest in traveling.This
choice has to be NO also. Eliminate this answer.
C.
He knew the second family before they came to his
farm. Turn
this to a question:
Are there any clues in the story to indicate he knew
the second family before they came to the farm?
What
does the story say when the second family shows up
at his farm?
In
the fall, another family on the move camped in the
orchard. As the farmer talked with them that evening,
the conversation was different.
This
isn't much to go on. We only know the second family
is described as being "on the move."
The discussion between the farmer and this family
was about moving on and what might occur in the future.
It was not about the past, or experiences they had
together in the past. There is not even a hint about
a past. We can infer the farmer did not know
the second family, because there are no clues to indicate
he did. This choice has to be NO also. Eliminate
this answer.
D.
He cares about the comfort of his guests. Turn
this to a question:
Did the farmer care about the comfort of his guests?
What
does the story say about how he treated his guests?
From
looking for clues for the other answers, we already
know that the farmer "readily agreed"
the campers could stay on his land. In addition,
he went to talk with them at night to see if they
were ok. The story says, "Late in the evening,
their host strolleddown to see if everything
was all right, and to pick up any news they
might have."
If
the farmer was concerned enough to see if "everything
was all right," we can make a smart guess
that he cared about the comfort of the campers.
This
inference makes sense from beginning to end of the
passage. You would show your smart guess and answer
YES!
Your turn! Here are the answers again. Read each one and
go through the process of turning the statement to a question.
Then, without looking at the explanations above, think your
way through each answer and select Yes,
No, Maybe.
Yes
No
Maybe
Answers
A.
He is reluctant to have visitors stay on his land.
B.
He himself would like to travel.
C.
He knew the second family before they came to his
farm.
D.
He cares about the comfort of his guests.
If you read carefully, you would
have chosen answer D.