Internet Academy ALP Reading
Assessment Lessons Helpful Tools Rubrics Index Home
Federal Way Public Schools  
Thinking Critically
Lesson 9
Evaluating Ideas and Themes
 Objectives/Vocab/Tips > Examples: 1 | 2 | 3 > Practice: 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 > Self Check

Example 3:

Instruction:

In the humorous fairy tale, "Young Ladies Don't Slay Dragons," the princess met all kinds of opposition in her quest to slay the dragon and save the kingdom. Being a determined and resourceful young lady, she did it anyway, saving the royal household, freeing the prince and winning herself a liberated husband in the bargain!


Young Ladies Don't Slay Dragons

Question:

Considering the theme

"It seemed to her that a young lady could do anything she wanted, if she set her mind to it."

and the outcome

she set her mind to it and she did it!

of the story, what is wrong with the King's reasoning that "Slaying dragons is men's work. . . and that's that."?

Remember to:

  • Read the question before reading the passage.
  • Read the first section of the story carefully, up to the King's order to his daughter the future dragon slayer!
  • Consider the Princess' eventual success in slaying the dragon as evidence when evaluating the King's response.

Think:

  • What are the key words in this question?
    (theme and outcome , wrong - King's reasoning)
  • Which choices can you eliminate right away, and which are possibly correct answers?
    Remember the "YES, NO, MAYBE" tool.
Remember: Sometimes we find support for an answer early in the story, but often we have to know the outcome and what happens after a character's statement or action in the story. In this question, the quote comes fairly early in the story to set up the background for the theme. It is what happens after that gives meaning to the King's statement.

Multiple Choice Answers:

Yes
No
Maybe
 
Answers
A. All the brave men in the kingdom have more important things to do and not one is interested in the reward for slaying the dragon.
B.

He is very proud of his daughter the princess,because her beauty is unsurpassed by any other princess on earth.

C.

He says that to convince his daughter to behave like other beautiful princesses, and go knit a sweater for the palace poodle.

D.

Slaying a dragon requires characteristics of both brains and bravery. The King does not recognize he is looking for characteristics, not gender.

Looks like D is an accurate evaluation because

  • it can be supported with clues and information from the story,
  • it makes sense from beginning to end of the story,
  • it relates to the theme of:
    It seemed that a young lady could do anything she waned, if she set her mind to it.
  • there is nothing in the story to contradict the evaluation.
Time to practice!

 

Assessments Vocabulary

©Internet Academy